Carrollwood Store Now Open at 14926 N. Dale Mabry

Thanksgiving Preorders

Cookies

Discounts for boxes of 4 ($2) , 6 ($3) and 12 ($12) will be applied at checkout.

Bakery

View all

Ice Cream

View all

Cookie Cakes

PREORDER ONLY, PLEASE ORDER DAY BEFORE NEEDED - NOT AVAILABLE FOR SHIPPING

Our cookie cakes are as thick and delicious as our cookies. We can make most of our cookie flavors into cookie cakes but the ones listed here are the tried and true favorites. If you are interested in anything not shown, please message us.

Drinks

View all

Let customers speak for us

from 74 reviews
Best in the state!

From a cookie connoisseur

Jerickson Fedrick
M&M, Chocolate Chip and Marshmallow
Fantastic!

I look forward to every Saturday to purchase cookies from The American Cookie Company. They’re the best cookies I’ve ever had and the owner, Roula, is an amazing person!

Miguel Washington
Cookies and Cream
THE BEST

Unfortunately there's isn't more locations yet but this place has the BEST COOKIES, Will make you say Crumble who....

Customer
Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk
Flavor town!

One of the best sleeper flavors at American Cookie company! Even if you’re not a lemon or fruit fan, you will absolutely fall in love with this cookie. It’s the perfect amount of white chocolate and perfect amount of lemon blended into the most scrumptious cookie. It’s top 3 cookies and the flavor never disappoints. A must try!!

Jane Mai
Lemon